← Practice & Compliance Guides
Practice checklistReading: 9 min

Revised November 2026.

Self-assessment grid: Law 25, PIPEDA and provincial privacy statutes

How a Quebec firm reviews its personal-information governance, record by record, before an examination.

In this guide

This self-assessment grid is for a Quebec firm of 1 to 30 lawyers that wants to measure, before a review, whether its governance of personal information holds under Law 25, the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector. It replaces neither the statute, nor advice from counsel, nor the duties of the Barreau du Québec and the Chambre des notaires. Professional secrecy, a matter of public order, attaches to the same files: the client’s confidence is also personal information, protected by articles 35 and following of the Civil Code of Québec, the code of ethics of advocates and the rules of the Chambre des notaires.

Regulatory foundations and reference texts

  • CQLR c. B-1, r. 5, ss. 49–56

    The named accounting register is not dumped into the incident file.

  • LSO By-Law 9, ss. 7–18

    By-Law 9 does not replace the Ontario privacy notice.

  • LSBC Rules, Part 3, Division 7

    British Columbia PIPA sits on top of Division 7.

  • LSA Rule 119

    Alberta PIPA sits on top of Rule 119.

  • CQLR c. P-39.1, ss. 3.1–3.8

    A named officer, an inventory, a PIA and an incident register.

  • S.C. 2000, c. 5, Schedule 1

    Outside Quebec, the Schedule 1 principles still apply.

Inspection pitfall versus the law society standard

Risky practice at inspection

The privacy officer, the inventory and professional secrecy

By default, the person who exercises the highest authority sees to compliance with the statute and may delegate that function in writing. The officer’s title and contact details are published on the website or made available by another clear means. The inventory makes the governance policies verifiable: for each category it notes the nature of the information, the purpose, the medium, the access, the hosting location and the period. Articles 35 and following of the Civil Code require a serious and legitimate interest to keep a file on a person. The Professional Code, the Barreau’s code of ethics and the rules of the Chambre des notaires add professional secrecy, which is a matter of public order. An access request that would reveal a confidence is answered within the limits of that secrecy. Appointing the officer and keeping the inventory remain due.

Consent, purpose and communication outside Quebec

The firm collects only the information necessary for the object of the file. Consent is manifest, free and informed, requested for each purpose in clear and simple terms, and separate from the other clauses of the retainer. Sensitive information requires express consent. A new purpose calls for fresh consent or an exception the statute provides. Before a communication outside Quebec, the privacy officer writes a privacy impact assessment. It weighs sensitivity, the purposes, the contractual measures and the legal regime of the destination. The communication takes place only if the assessment finds adequate protection, in principle equivalent to Quebec’s. Hosting the servers in Montreal is not enough when a foreign company can reach the file without that framework.

Reading grid for a Law 25 self-assessment in a firm
Control pointWhat the file must showGap that blocks the grid
Privacy officerWritten delegation where there is one, title and contact details published, governance policies in plain language.A silent website, or a delegation that exists only orally.
InventoryCategories, purposes, media, access, hosting location and periods, including email and backups.A system used every day and missing from the list.
ConsentPurpose, date, channel and, where the information is sensitive, the express character of consent.A clause buried in the retainer, or a new purpose without fresh consent.
Outside QuebecA written privacy impact assessment and a contract that restates the protective measures.A backup with a foreign vendor and no assessment.
IncidentAn up-to-date register, an analysis of the risk of serious injury, notice to the Commission and to the persons if the threshold is met.A known incident left unrecorded, or notice omitted when the risk is serious.
RetentionA deadline by file type and proof of destruction or anonymization once the purpose is achieved.Files with no deadline, or destruction asserted with no trace.

Incidents, notice to the Commission and the end of retention

A confidentiality incident is access, use or communication not authorized by law, or the loss of personal information. The firm reduces the risk of injury and prevents a repeat. Every incident enters the register, with the circumstances, the date of awareness, the assessment of the risk of serious injury and the measures. The register stays current for at least five years after that awareness. If the risk is serious, the privacy officer promptly notifies the Commission d’accès à l’information and the persons concerned. The notice sets out the facts without copying the confidence, whether the author is an advocate of the Barreau or a notary of the Chambre. Once the purpose is achieved, the information is destroyed or anonymized, subject to any period the statute or the rules of the Barreau and the Chambre still impose. Destruction is dated, and the inventory is corrected the same day.

  1. Confirm the privacy officer. — Check the written delegation, where there is one, and publication of the title and contact details.
  2. Complete the inventory. — List each category, its purpose, its medium, its access, its hosting and its period, including email and backups.
  3. Reread the consents. — On a sample of matters, confirm the purpose, the date and, if the information is sensitive, the express consent.
  4. Assess transfers outside Quebec. — For each vendor outside Quebec, attach the written assessment and the contract that restates the protective measures.
  5. Keep the register. — Enter each known incident, with the date of awareness, the analysis of the risk of serious injury and the measures taken.
  6. Send the notices. — If the risk is serious, promptly notify the Commission d’accès à l’information and the persons concerned, without handing over the confidence.
  7. Close retention. — Apply the professional-file period, destroy or anonymize what no longer has a purpose, then correct the inventory.

What changes under the common law: LSO By-Law 9, LSBC, LSA, LSNB, PIPEDA/PIPA

Law 25 governs personal information in the private sector in Quebec. A federal work, undertaking or business is governed by PIPEDA. Outside Quebec, a commercial private practice is also governed by PIPEDA, except in Alberta and British Columbia, where the provincial PIPA governs personal information. The rules of the common-law law societies govern trust accounting and professional conduct. In Ontario, Law Society of Ontario By-Law 9 governs trust accounts, and the conduct rules govern practice. Personal information in a commercial private practice is governed there by PIPEDA. In British Columbia, the rules of the Law Society of British Columbia govern trust accounting and conduct, and the provincial PIPA governs personal information. In Alberta, the rules of the Law Society of Alberta do the same for accounts and conduct, and Alberta’s PIPA covers personal information. In New Brunswick, the Law Society of New Brunswick governs trust accounting and conduct, and personal information in a commercial practice is governed by PIPEDA.

Pan-Canadian guide to Law 25, PIPEDA and provincial privacy statutes

Deterministic check

1. Legal jurisdiction of the software publisher and cloud subprocessors
2. Physical location of databases and encrypted backups
3. Confidentiality-incident register and notification protocol (CAI / OPC)
4. Separation of sensitive files (ethical walls / RBAC) and an immutable audit log
5. Traceability of client consent and the retention and destruction schedule